Article 27 in our 30-part series. Dorothy Lou Thompson’s life before the 1985 Louisiana cold case crossed Oklahoma, Kansas City and the bayou community of St. Bernard Parish. This biography follows the public historical record and distinguishes documented events from disputed family lore.
Early years in Oklahoma and Kansas City
Published biographies place Dorothy Lou Wynne’s birth in Oklahoma in 1924. Her mother, Grace Agnes Matt, married John “Jack” Thompson before later marrying Arthur Wynne. Dorothy used the Thompson surname and reportedly called Jack “Daddy Jack.” These family details appear in historical accounts and court-related reporting; they should be read as reported background rather than a simple, uncontested family tree.
Moving to Louisiana
Histories of the property say Grace and Dorothy were living in Louisiana by 1946. They settled at the former Toca Plantation in St. Bernard Parish, near Bayou Terre aux Boeufs. The rural setting later became inseparable from the story of the family’s pet cemetery.
The family pet cemetery
According to published histories, Grace’s plan for a pet cemetery grew from the difficulty of finding a suitable burial place for a beloved dog. By about 1952, she was running the cemetery full-time. Dorothy later became closely associated with its operation. Accounts describe thousands of animal graves, making it a local business long before the property became known through a true-crime case.
Her life before the 1985 case
Dorothy’s adult life included two husbands who died in separate shootings. Reporting says authorities treated the 1970 death of her first husband, Logan Banks, as self-defense and filed no charges. Her second husband, Donald Robinson, was found shot in 1978; Dorothy was not charged in that case either. These events do not establish that Dorothy killed either man.
After Grace died in 1979, Dorothy hired Brandon Nodier for repairs and as a live-in caretaker. A property dispute followed, and Dorothy filed a lawsuit alleging she had been misled about a transfer of the cemetery. She disappeared in April 1985; her body was found in the Mississippi River on May 2. Nodier later pleaded guilty to manslaughter in July 2014 and received a 10-year sentence.
Watch the official HBO trailer
Frequently asked questions
Where was Dorothy born?
Published accounts place her birth in Oklahoma in 1924.
When did the family move to Louisiana?
Property histories place Grace and Dorothy in St. Bernard Parish by 1946.
Who founded Azalea Original Pet Cemetery?
Grace Wynne is generally credited with founding the cemetery; Dorothy later became closely associated with running it.
Was Dorothy charged in her husbands’ deaths?
No. Reporting says she was not charged in either case.
Sources and further reading
- Biography.com — Dorothy Lou Thompson
- Autopsy of Architecture — property history and archival photographs
- WVUE/FOX 8 — 2014 sentencing report
- WVUE/FOX 8 — investigation report
- Gone South — case history transcript
- Warner Bros. Discovery — official HBO programming information
Editorial note: This article distinguishes historical reporting from allegations. Images are credited to identified sources; check image licensing before commercial reuse. No X/Twitter or Instagram post is embedded unless an authentic, relevant public post can be verified.
